Mayo Cafe

Reviews

• Cyn C.

  star star star star star 13 July 2026

  I don't like Mac-n-Cheese particularly.  I want to move to Mayo, Florida so I can eat the Mayo Cafe's Mac-n-Cheese.  A meat-n-three buffet that fulfilled my Southern soul's need for greens and peas on New Year's Day.  And taught me to crave Mac-n-Cheese.
  
  Beef so tender, it could be cut with a fork.  Fried chicken fit to take to a family reunion.  Mashed potatoes that had been peeled and boiled that morning.  
  
  If it's on your way, stop and eat.  If it's not on your way, change your route.

• Connie O.

  star star star star_border star_border 13 July 2026

  Well this is a place I normally would not stop at but our favourite mayo haunt was closed and we were hungry. A little messy, tables a little sticky, deer head with fly traps on the antlers...i kid you not, see pic . But if you can get past all of that and grew up in a small little town like me you might be surprised. Food was pretty good. Buffet looked tasty although we ordered off menu. I would not drive to eat here but I would go back.

• Mary V.

  star star star star star 3 July 2026

  New to the area and this restaurant is the best home cooking besides my own.  Thank your for the kind service. This will be our regular stop for breakfast, lunch and dinner.

• Chris C.

  star star star star star 23 June 2026

  Small unassuming hometown roadside cafe. I was traveling in an rv and wanted a quick lunch so pulled in. Not much to look at but I was warmly greeted by staff. I explained I just wanted a something to go and she said I could order off the menu or fill a to go container from the buffet.  So upon inspection I said that buffet will do nicely. Wow. Salad to desert with many options. I loved their bar-b-q chicken. Slathered in a sweet sauce and fork tender. Their Lima beans Cooke with ham altho a bit overdone was not salty and very tasty. And I had green beans and corn and a pasta dish and a slice of cornbread. Plus banana and chocolate pudding. All for $9.57!  It's a busy place.

• Jordan S.

  star star star star star_border 22 June 2026

  The food here is great! We love spending the weekend on the Suwannee river and this is the perfect place to enjoy dinner afterwards. Prices are great for the buffet.
  
  I'm rating 4 stars though because once the food was gone, which was very quickly for the size of our party, nothing was replenished. We asked for more macaroni and was told there was none, a few minutes later they put out some that they found- but it was ice cold. Gross.